Make a Payment Most insurance companies provide the option to make a payment by EFT, e-check, or credit card. To make a payment, select your insurance company below, and you will be directed to their payment site. American Collectors Insurance CompanyForemost Insurance CompanyNew York State Insurance FundAllegany Co-Op InsuranceInterboro/AutoOneProgressive Insurance CompanyCNA SuretyMAPFRE InsuranceSuperior Payment PlanCondon SkellyMidrox Insurance CompanyTravelers Insurance CompanyFarmers Insurance CompanyNew York Central Mutual