The Tilly Agency strives to offer you the best coverage at competitive prices through our many trusted carriers.
We represent only the best companies. For the sake of our valued customers, we have come to expect a high level of quality from the companies we represent.
Many of our companies offer online policy payments. The following companies have lived up to the expectations we put forth:
New York Central Mutual
The largest regional personal lines insurance company in New York State, offering great rates with great service. Proudly serving our insureds with homeowner, automobile, mobile home, umbrella, and commercial insurance for over 100 years. NYCM offers online bill payments.
A. Central Insurance
A wholly owned subsidiary of NYCM, A. Central insures private passenger automobiles for people with a “less then perfect record”. A. Central prides itself on providing quality insurance and great service at affordable rates.
A. Central allows online bill payments.
Progressive
Progressive offers Personal and Commercial Automobile Policies as well as ATV, Motorcycle, Snowmobile, and Boat, RV, Golf Carts, and Personal Watercraft Insurance.
Progressive allows online bill payments.
Dryden Mutal
Dryden Mutual offers Homeowners, Mobile Homeowners, Fire, Contractors, and Manufacturers Insurance. They also offer insurance on Vacant Buildings, and other types of Commercial Insurance
Travelers
Travelers offers a variety of policies. This includes Home, Auto, Umbrella, Flood and Boat Insurance.
Travelers allows online bill payments.
Traverse
Traverse, powered by Travelers, offers insurance for your phone, electronics, musical instruments, sporting equipment, and more, at al low monthly price.
Allegany Co-op
Allegany Co-op offers Home, Business, Contractor and Farm policies. Allegany Co-op is committed to providing their policyholders the very best in coverage and service.
Midrox
Midrox offers insurance on Small Farms and Ranches. They also offer Homeowner’s Insurance. Contractors and Restaurants can also be insured through Midrox.
Foremost
Foremost offers Insurance on Travel Trailers and Mobile Homes as well as Dwelling Fire Policies, and Insurance on Specialty Dwellings. They also offer Automobile Insurance.
Genesee Patrons
Genesee Patrons offers Homeowner, Mobile Home, Farmowner, and Land Lord’s Package(LLP) Insurance.
AutoOne
AutoOne is based in Mineola, New York with a satellite office in Syracuse, New York. AutoOne is a market leader in New York, where it also offers voluntary automobile products such as private passenger and take-out programs to qualified drivers.
ShelterPoint
